Living on Crotches or UI Automation Antipatterns

on YouTube ↗32m

" summary

Shows how common UI automation antipatterns — an imbalance of few unit tests vs many flaky UI tests, over-engineered frameworks, and bad practices like 300–500 useless UI scripts, hardcoded credentials/URLs, duplicated Gherkin scenarios and brittle conditional assertions — sink projects. Recommends concrete fixes: map manual test cases to automated suites, parameterize runs via command-line or CI (Maven/CI), extract test-data constants, and add custom matcher messages so failures explain why.

AI-written summary · about

" chapters (11)

1. 0:00UI automation intro
2. 2:07Testing pyramid antipatterns
3. 7:26Antipattern 'And off we go'
4. 10:18Positive tests limits
5. 12:54Antipattern 'No easy way'
6. 17:26Antipattern 'Fill all fields'
7. 20:18Gherkin limitations
8. 23:49Hardcoded test data
9. 26:25Hardcoded config
10. 29:18Antipattern 'Something broke'
11. 30:44Q&A

" related talks

• 36mLiving on crotches or UI Automation antipatternsVadzim Zubovich · TestCon Vilnius 2017
• 46mFlaky, Fragile, and Forgotten: The Fall of a Test Automation ProjectMesut Durukal · TestMu Conference 2026
• 51mRedefining test automationRichard Bradshaw · SeleniumConf London 2019
• 36mIt's not your test framework, it's youRobbie Clutton, Matt Parker · LA RubyConf 2013
• 54mTest Automation Transformation Avoiding the 7 Common PitfallsPaul Chorley · TestCon Europe 2023
• 57mAdvanced Testing Techniques: Tips from the trenchesRob Moore, Graeme Foster · NDC Sydney 2018
• 36mIt's not your test framework, it's youRobbie Clutton, Matt Parker · LA RubyConf 2013
• 50mAsaf Shochet Avida, Eitan Noy: Why My Amazing Test Automation Project CrumbledAsaf Shochet Avida, Eitan Noy · TestCon Europe 2024