Are We Really Engineers?

on YouTube ↗37m

" summary

Interviews with 17 crossovers (12 hours total) probe whether software counts as engineering and report 15 of 17 say yes, with nuance: software’s key differences are iteration speed, reliance on discrete math, and high consistency, while traditional fields face physical inconsistency and regulatory rigor. Concrete examples include Boeing 737 Max software-stabilizer tradeoffs, moving bridges, and tiny “snap fit” design books. A repeated takeaway: other engineers crave version control and practitioner-style openness.

AI-written summary · about

" chapters (15)

1. 0:00Intro
2. 3:48Methodology
3. 5:14Whats Engineering
4. 6:19Is Engineering Physical
5. 8:49Is Engineering consequential
6. 10:43Is Engineering licensed
7. 15:57Software vs Traditional Engineering
8. 18:08Engineering is predictable
9. 22:48Engineering is more rigorous
10. 26:16Whats different
11. 28:16Consistency
12. 30:24Are we special
13. 33:10What can we learn
14. 34:49Version Control
15. 36:14Final Thoughts

" related talks

• 38mIs Software Engineering Real Engineering?Hillel Wayne · GOTO Chicago 2023
• 40mIs Software Engineering Real Engineering?Hillel Wayne · YOW! Perth 2023
• 58mIs Software Engineering Still an Oxymoron?Alan Kay · GOTO Copenhagen 2021
• 42mwhy software development is an engineering disciplineGlenn Vanderburg · O'Reilly Software Architecture Conference 2015
• 55mEngineering for SoftwareDave Farley · YOW! Melbourne 2022
• 47m‘Engineering' for Software - How to Amplify CreativityDave Farley · GOTO Copenhagen 2021
• 01h 01mEngineering for Software - How to Amplify CreativityDave Farley · YOW! Melbourne 2022
• 35mCraft, Engineering, and the Essence of ProgrammingGlenn Vanderburg · RailsConf 2011